How to Close the Say-Do Gap® and Build Trust in Your Church Communications

Does your church say one thing but do another? You might have a Say-Do Gap®.

This disconnect—the gap between what your church says it believes and how it behaves—can quietly undermine trust and weaken relationships. It impacts not only your congregation but also your broader community.

When people sense inconsistency between your church’s stated belief and its actions, they disengage. Visitors seeking hope may look elsewhere, and members may feel undervalued or disconnected. Over time, your church’s impact diminishes, and opportunities for transformation are lost.

Here’s the good news: closing the Say-Do Gap® is entirely possible. By aligning your communication with your belief and ensuring your actions back up your words, you can rebuild trust, foster engagement, and amplify your church’s mission.

What is the Say-Do Gap®?

The Say-Do Gap® is the disconnect between what a church claims to believe and how it communicates or acts on those beliefs. This subtle but powerful gap often goes unnoticed by leadership but is felt deeply by those in the congregation and beyond.

Examples of the Say-Do Gap® in Action:

• Focusing Only on Internal Events: When communication prioritizes ministry updates, event schedules, or logistical details, external audiences feel overlooked. An example – someone seeking hope might visit your website and only find an event calendar. What they needed was a message of encouragement or a practical resource to help them through a challenge.
• Generic Messaging That Fails to Reflect Belief: Churches often share vague or transactional messages like, “Don’t miss this Sunday’s potluck,” rather than belief-driven content that inspires. Messaging disconnected from your belief leaves audiences uninspired and disengaged.
• Inconsistent Action: If your church says it’s committed to “serving the community” but rarely engages in outreach, the inconsistency damages credibility. The Say-Do Gap® isn’t about bad intentions—it’s about the misalignment between belief, messaging, and actions.

Why It Matters

Failing to close the Say-Do Gap® can lead to significant consequences for your church:

• Disengagement: Members may feel undervalued or disconnected, leading to reduced participation and declining morale. And visitors seeking hope may leave before they’ve had a chance to connect with your church.
• Missed Opportunities to Share Hope: Misaligned communication often overlooks the struggles that your audience faces. When your messaging doesn’t address topics like mental health, parenting challenges, or spiritual questions, opportunities to provide hope are missed.
• Erosion of Trust: The Say-Do Gap® creates confusion about what your church truly stands for. Over time, this inconsistency erodes trust—the foundation of any thriving ministry.

A Real-World Example

A mid-sized church in Texas faced disengagement among its members. Communication was heavily focused on internal updates, leaving members feeling out of touch with the church’s belief and purpose. By implementing a belief-aligned communication strategy—including outward-facing initiatives and storytelling—they saw a 30% increase in attendance and a 50% rise in volunteer engagement within six-months.

How to Close the Say-Do Gap®

Closing the Say-Do Gap® requires intentional, belief-driven communication and action. Here are three steps to help align your messaging with your church’s calling:

• Align Every Message with Your Core Belief: Start by identifying your church’s core belief—the “why” behind everything you do. Then, ensure every sermon, email, and social media post reflects and reinforces this belief. For example, if your church believes in “bringing hope and healing to the broken,” focus your communication on stories, resources, and events that demonstrate this mission in action. Share transformation stories, initiatives serving the marginalized, or tools for people seeking hope. When every message is anchored in your belief, it builds trust and credibility.
• Use Belief-Driven Storytelling: Stories are one of the most effective tools for inspiring and building trust. Real, tangible stories of how your church’s actions align with its belief create powerful connections. An actionable tactic is to highlight stories of transformation in sermons, emails, and social media posts to share how individuals have been impacted by your church’s ministry or events. For example, instead of posting, “Join us for this week’s small group,” share a story of how a small group helped someone navigate a challenging season of life. Belief-driven storytelling inspires trust and invites people to take part in your mission.

The Opportunity: Transform Your Communication Strategy

The Say-Do Gap® isn’t just a communications issue—it’s a trust issue. And trust is essential for building strong relationships within your congregation and your community. When your church aligns its words and actions, you:

• Build trust and credibility with members and visitors.
• Inspire engagement by demonstrating your belief in action.
• Create opportunities for transformation and growth within your community.

YOUR NEW COMMS PLAN

Learn how your church can apply an approach that businesses have used to successfully acquire new customers and retain existing customers. Use the power of audience segmentation to deliver personalized messages that are relevant to each person within you external and internal church community.

download